Ferrari is sued by U.S. drivers over brake defect

Ferrari has been sued in the United States by drivers who said the Italian luxury sports car maker has failed to fix vehicles at risk of a partial or total loss of braking capability.

According to a proposed class action filed on Monday in San Diego federal court, recalls in 2021 and 2022 to address leaking brake fluid were only an interim measure, allowing Ferrari to keep selling thousands of cars with defective brakes.

The complaint said the only fix was to replace defective master cylinders when leaks are found.

“Ferrari was legally required to disclose the brake defect as a known safety defect and failed to do so,” according to the complaint, which sought unspecified damages for drivers.

In a statement on Tuesday, Ferrari did not specifically address the lawsuit but said its “highest priority” was the safety and well-being of its drivers.

“We operate according to stringent safety and security guidelines to ensure that our vehicles always respect homologation specifications,” Ferrari added.

The lawsuit is led by Iliya Nechev, a San Marcos, California, resident who bought his 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia in 2020.

Nechev said he “came close to an accident several times” because of his Ferrari’s brakes, but his dealership said they were “normal” and he should “just get used to them.” He said he wouldn’t have bought his Ferrari had he known of the problems.

Ferrari issued brake recalls in several countries including the United States and China starting in October 2021.

The U.S. recalls covered many Ferrari models, including versions of the 458 and 488, produced over nearly two decades.

Ferrari and Robert Bosch, the German supplier of the alleged defective parts, have said problems could result from brake reservoir fluid caps that might not vent properly, potentially creating a vacuum inside the fluid reservoir.

Bosch is also a defendant. It did not immediately respond on Tuesday to a request for comment. The five law firms that represent Nechev did not immediately respond to requests for additional comment.

The case is Nechev v. Ferrari North America Inc et al, U.S. District Court, Southern District of California, No. 24-00516.