AM Best Downgrades Issuer Credit Rating of Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Company
Affirms Financial Strength Rating
Major rating agency AM Best has revised its Long-Term Issuer Credit Rating (Long-Term ICR) for Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Company (Warwick, RI), marking a shift from “bbb+” (Good) to “bbb” (Good). Despite this, the Financial Strength Rating remains unaltered at B++ (Good).
AM Best has also shifted its outlook for the company’s Long-Term ICR from negative to stable while maintaining a stable outlook for its Financial Strength Rating.
The new ratings, as explained by AM Best, are a reflection of several aspects:
Providence Mutual’s balance sheet strength is rated as very strong.
Providence Mutual’s marginal operating performance.
The business profile of the company is limited.
The company’s marginal Enterprise Risk Management (ERM)l.
A major factor contributing to the downgrade in Long-Term ICR is AM Best’s increasing concern regarding Providence Mutual’s ERM’s effectiveness. This apprehension specifically addresses the company’s capability to combat ongoing operational difficulties. Over the past five years, Providence Mutual has faced a series of challenges, such as severe weather occurrences, an escalated frequency of large losses, pricing discrepancies in its personal auto business, and, recently, inflation’s impact on loss costs.
In response to these trials, the management has implemented a number of changes. These include:
Implementing rate increases across its operational states and core lines of business.
Introducing more restrictive underwriting guidelines.
Enhancing attention to agency management.
Lowering its risk appetite for unsupported auto business.
Decreasing coastal exposures.
Despite these measures, the firm’s operating performance continues to be negatively influenced by volatility, which hinders its ability to generate organic surplus growth through core operations.
The stable outlook is driven by AM Best’s anticipation that Providence Mutual will sustain its very strong balance sheet strength over the intermediate term. This is expected to be bolstered by the highest level of risk-adjusted capitalization, as quantified by Best’s Capital Adequacy Ratio (BCAR), even amidst surplus volatility stemming from operating losses and equity market fluctuations in recent years. Furthermore, the outlook takes into account the various performance improvement initiatives implemented by management to counter marginal performance metrics. AM Best projects that these efforts will yield improved results over time.
